
A transition is not just because it is announced. It is just when people are protected, livelihoods are strengthened and finance reaches those on the frontlines. That is the outcome COP31 must deliver.
As COP31 enters its final negotiating stretch in Antalya, the question is no longer whether governments can write ambitious climate language. It is whether they will finance and deliver it. Day 9 exposed a widening gap between promises made in public and decisions still being contested behind closed doors. For communities facing drought, floods, rising food prices, damaged livelihoods and unreliable energy, this gap is not diplomatic procedure: it is the difference between recovery and deeper hardship.
The most important test remains climate finance. Developing countries are pressing for adaptation finance to be tripled, with a clear minimum floor, baseline and timetable. Yet the negotiations are still divided over how this should be delivered and how the Climate Finance Work Programme should operate. The African Group has stressed that climate finance must not push African countries further into debt. This is a basic justice issue: countries and communities that have contributed least to the climate crisis should not be asked to borrow their way out of its impacts.
There were new contributions, but they must be seen in context. On 17 November, governments announced US$200 million for the Global Environment Facility family of funds. The Adaptation Fund received €41 million in pledges from Spain, Germany and Ireland, while Spain pledged €15 million to the Fund for Responding to Loss and Damage. These contributions matter, but they are not yet proof that finance is adequate, predictable or reaching frontline households. The Loss and Damage Fund is also facing requests of about US$2.8 billion under its Barbados Implementation Modalities, while countries continue to debate replenishment, direct access and faster disbursement.
For a farmer whose harvest has failed, a fisher whose coast is eroding, or a family forced to leave home after a climate disaster, a pledge announced in a conference hall is not protection. Finance must arrive as accessible grants, support local organisations and public services, and help people restore homes, livelihoods, health and food security. It must not disappear into complex procedures or become another debt obligation.
The just transition negotiations also remain unsettled. Countries disagree on the form and mandate of a proposed Just Transition Mechanism, including whether it should have a dedicated institutional structure, how it should relate to the existing Just Transition Work Programme, and how it will be financed. African countries, including Ghana and Uganda, have supported options for an implementation-oriented structure. Civil society representatives have called for meaningful participation by workers, Indigenous Peoples, women, young people and local communities. The message is straightforward: workers and communities cannot be an afterthought in plans to change energy systems, industries and economies.
There is movement on energy. More than 30 countries are reported to support the 35-by-35 electrification pledge, which seeks to raise electricity’s share of global final energy use to 35% by 2035. New or announced roadmaps to transition away from fossil fuels have also come from a growing group of countries and regions. But electrification is not automatically just or clean. It must be powered increasingly by renewable energy, supported by reliable grids and storage, and designed to deliver affordable electricity, decent work and local economic value, not new dependence on fossil fuels or projects that displace communities.
A significant step forward came in transparency. At the 17 November ministerial dialogue, UN Climate Change Executive Secretary Simon Stiell reported that the first 137 Biennial Transparency Reports show 61 Parties, representing about 66% of global emissions in 2020, making progress towards their national climate targets. He also warned that progress remains far from sufficient. Transparency matters because communities have a right to know what governments promise, what money is received, where it is spent and whether it is reducing harm.
From GreenFaith Africa’s perspective, COP31 must now connect the negotiating text to the realities of people. Social protection should be built into just transition plans: income support when livelihoods are disrupted, skills and decent jobs for workers, protection for women, youth and informal workers, stronger public services, and support for households hit by climate shocks. Faith communities and grassroots organisations can help reach people, identify needs and hold institutions accountable but they must be properly resourced and included in decisions.
Our message to negotiators is clear: do not leave Antalya with another collection of promises that communities cannot access. Agree a credible pathway to scale adaptation finance; strengthen and replenish the Loss and Damage Fund with grant-based resources and simpler direct access; establish an effective, inclusive Just Transition Mechanism; and ensure that electrification accelerates renewable energy access, jobs and community ownership